Selling a House in Stoneleigh
Stoneleigh was planned in 1922 and built out mostly by 1954, a streetcar suburb along York Road that’s been on the National Register of Historic Places since 2003. Its Colonial Revival houses, Cape Cods and stone houses sell for more than twice the median of neighboring Rodgers Forge, and no two are quite alike, so pricing takes more judgment than in a rowhouse neighborhood.
Updated November 2026
What Stoneleigh homes have sold for
In the 12 months to November 11, 2026, 23 Stoneleigh homes sold through Bright MLS, from $529,000 to $1,684,000, with a median of $965,000 and an average of 14 days on the market. With about two sales a month, one sale can move the median, so I price from the closest matches, not the median.
Source: Bright MLS, closed residential sales in Stoneleigh, pulled November 11, 2026. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed. I refresh these every few months.
What moves the price
Lot size, a garage, additions and primary suites, and how recently the kitchen and baths were done. Those differences are a big part of why the last 12 months ran from $529,000 to $1,684,000, and why I walk the house before I give you a number.
The covenants
Stoneleigh is a covenant community: its deeds carry restrictions written when the Stoneleigh Corporation developed the neighborhood in the 1920s. Read what yours says before you list, and keep the paperwork for any additions or exterior changes in one place. The National Register listing doesn’t add restrictions by itself.
What buyers and inspectors look at
- Older roofs, chimneys, and stone or stucco repair
- Original wiring, galvanized plumbing and older boilers
- Drainage and basement water
- An old oil tank, if the house ever heated with oil; see selling a Towson house with an oil tank
More on what’s worth fixing: what to fix before selling in Towson.
What I bring
Stoneleigh is part of my home base, and running Property Management of Baltimore since 2014 means I know what fixing an old system really costs. Since 2023, my listings have sold for a median 103.6% of the original asking price, in a median of 6 days on the market. More on the neighborhood: the Stoneleigh neighborhood guide and Rodgers Forge vs. Stoneleigh home prices.
Questions people ask
How much are Stoneleigh homes selling for?
In the 12 months to November 11, 2026, 23 sold through Bright MLS from $529,000 to $1,684,000, with a median of $965,000 and an average of 14 days on the market.
Does Stoneleigh have covenants?
Yes. They’re in the deeds and date to the neighborhood’s 1920s development. Read yours before you list.
Is Stoneleigh a historic district?
It’s been a National Register district since 2003, which doesn’t restrict private changes by itself.
How fast do Stoneleigh homes sell?
The average was 14 days on the market across 23 sales in the 12 months to November 11, 2026. Price and condition move that more than the season.
About Mike Fielder
Mike Fielder is a Baltimore Realtor and Sales Director of The Key Home Team at Cummings & Co. Realtors. Licensed since June 2016, he focuses on North Baltimore (Lake Evesham, Lake Walker, Cedarcroft, Hampden and Remington) and the Towson area. He works with buyers and sellers throughout Maryland and in parts of Pennsylvania, where he’s also licensed. He also serves as Vice President of the Lake Evesham Community Association.
Over his career, Mike has sold 190 homes worth more than $56 million. He’s backed by The Key Home Team, which has sold more than $375 million in real estate and closes about $30 million a year.
Mike founded Property Management of Baltimore in 2014, two years before getting his license, and still runs it. Managing rentals taught him what repairs really cost, which updates buyers pay for, and how to keep a deal moving when something breaks. Sellers get that judgment when deciding what to fix before listing. Buyers get it when they’re reading an inspection report.
A Towson University graduate, Mike keeps his approach simple: price from real recent sales, spend money only where it pays back, and compare offers by what the client actually keeps.
More from Mike: Towson on mikesellsbaltimore.com · Selling with Mike · Full bio
Thinking about selling in Stoneleigh?
Get your home value, and I’ll pull the sales that actually match your house. Or call me at 410-905-6678.
The Key Home Team of Cummings & Co. Realtors
Cell: 410-905-6678
Email: [email protected]
Office: 410-823-0033
222 W Cold Spring Ln, Suite C, Baltimore, MD 21210
Website: mikesellsbaltimore.com